We had no plan for Jerusalem. When our bus pulled into the station, the only things we wanted to accomplish on our first night was to buy a guidebook and find some Matzah Ball soup. This magical city had other ideas. Within two hours we found ourselves standing within the walls of the Old City in a sea of sparkling lights.
It all started when we decided to book the cheapest hostel in Jerusalem. Coming from Dahab (where our awesome hostel cost a whopping $20 a night), it was quite a shock to see that the worst hostels in Jerusalem start at $100 per night. Just when we were beginning to give up hope, we saw that Trip Advisor’s #2 hotel in all of Jerusalem was available for just $40 USD per day. It seemed too good to be true, but the Trip Advisor reviews were so favorable we decided to take the chance.
We should have known something was up when none of the taxi drivers at the bus station seemed to know the hotel. When we finally found a cab driver to take us there, we discovered that the hostel was in East Jerusalem – the Palestinian section of city.
Erin: As we stood in middle of our sparsely decorated room in East Jerusalem, my first thought was: Should we move? But before I could even pose the question, the hotel’s manager knocked at our door to deliver a full bowl of fruit and two cups of deliciously rich chocolate ice-cream. I’ve stayed in a lot of hotels on this trip, but none knew me well enough to deliver ice cream to my door upon arrival. We had to give the place a chance…
Jeff: This wasn’t exactly where I thought we’d spend our first night in the Jewish homeland. But everyone at the hotel was very nice and I thought it would be interesting to see the city from a different perspective.
When we ventured into our neighborhood to find some food it felt like we were still in Egypt. The women wore headscarves, the men looked Egyptian, and all of the signs for the shops and restaurants were in Arabic. Our chances of finding some Kosher food for dinner fell from slim to none.
Thinking we’d have better luck in West Jerusalem, we started to make our way down past the Old City when we noticed the lights.

As we got closer, we found ourselves swept into a sea of people all making their way to the gates of the Old City. It was the first night of the “Light in Jerusalem” festival. Typically empty at night, the Old City was teeming with people and electricity.

We thought it was exceedingly nice (and truly unnecessary) for them to organize a festival just to celebrate our arrival in the city. We were a little tired but we thought it would be rude if we didn’t stop and enjoy the festivities they had prepared especially for us. We spent a few hours enjoying the beautifully lit landscapes and art installations.


We returned to the Old Quarter the next day to see the place in an entirely different light. Thursday is “Bar Mitzvah” day at the Western Wall and witnessed several festive comings-of-age.

In addition to being the homeland for Jews, Jerusalem is also an important site in the history of the Christian religion. We saw where Jesus Christ was born, where he was condemned, where he received the cross, where he died, and where he ascended into heaven.

Church of the Holy Sepulchre - Site of Jesus' Crucifixion
According to our guidebook, most historians and archeologists agree that many of these revered sites were probably located in a different part of Jerusalem. We decided not to let a little science get in the way of our Christian pilgrimage through the old city.
Although Jerusalem doesn’t feature prominently in Islamic religious texts (the city is not mentioned in the Koran), there is a strong historical connection between Islam and Jerusalem. After Mohammed’s death, his successor (Caliph Omar) captured Jerusalem from the Byzantines in 638 and began constructing Islamic sites in the city. The most famous is the Dome of the Rock Mosque, which was later claimed to be the site that Mohammad visited in a dream before his death. Various Islamic dynasties based in Syria, Turkey and Egypt controlled Jerusalem for the next 1,300 years and re-built the beautiful mosque several times.

Unfortunately, Jerusalem’s rich historical and religious history is the very thing that tears the city apart. There is an anxious energy that lies just below the surface of the city, most likely fueled by the strong presence of Israeli army soldiers and by the Palestinian flags that adorn many buildings in the east side of the city.
At first we were apprehensive about staying in the Palestinian section of the city, but in the end we were very glad for the experience. Jerusalem is a city divided, but it is also integrated in important ways. We met two of our neighbors who describe themselves as Palestinians but who are students at the Hebrew University and take all their classes in Hebrew. They went out of their way to help us – giving us a ride in their car, showing us around the University, and helping us navigate the bus system.
Although most of the Palestinians we met in our neighborhood were great, we met others who clearly carried around a lot of anger with them. One afternoon we hailed a taxi driven by a Palestinian man. Instead of starting his meter, he began to negotiate a fare for our ride. We explained we didn’t want to negotiate and told him to either start his meter or let us out. He didn’t let us out, but he didn’t start his meter either.
This should have been a routine argument with a taxi driver (we’ve had many in Washington DC and on this trip), but our driver quickly lost his temper. The situation escalated into a shouting match and then a physical struggle as he tried to prevent Jeff from getting out of the car at a stoplight. Once we were safely out of the car, he cursed at us and at our country and threw his coffee at us. Luckily the coffee was cold and he only managed to hit Jeff’s leg.
As we stood on the side of the road in East Jerusalem trying to regain our composure and wiping the coffee of Jeff’s leg, we tried to process exactly what just happened. This may have been an isolated incident by one disgruntled cab driver. But this confrontation could also speak to the resentment that lies just under the surface in Jerusalem. We’re not sure but the tension in Jerusalem is so thick it’s almost palatable.
We decided to cheer ourselves up with a trip to Ben Yehuda street, the pedestrian downtown area in the middle of the west Jerusalem. We ordered a falafel and some pizza from the street vendors, and had one of the most memorable meals of this trip while sitting on a bench in the middle of the street. The falafels were incredible and the pizza was as good as anything you can get on the east side of Manhattan.
Jerusalem was a great introduction to our Israel trip. We decided to rent a car and set out to explore the rest of this beautiful and controversial country on our own.